The Dream Within The ‘Dream Team’: Football As A Zimbabwean Metaphor

When Zimbabweans invoke memories of “the good old days” of the country’s rise and prosperity, a range of popular culture symbols and metaphors are often associated with this harkening to what seemed a perfect past. Witty television advertisements are reconstructed, the allegoric music of that time is replayed and incisive characters from literature and film are re-membered. Also not far from many Zimbabweans’ memories is the ‘Dream Team’, Zimbabwe’s iconic national football team, so named in the early 1990s for the new sporting feats it promised and excited in the nation’s collective imagination.

Featuring an eclectic mix of skills and experience, this was a superstar team bound for footballing greatness with qualifications for the African Cup of Nations and World Cup eagerly anticipated – and expected – by its multitudes of fans. As Ian Hawkey observed in an essay from 2015 about the team’s anchors, striker Peter Ndlovu (who played his club football with Coventry City) and goalkeeper Bruce Grobbelaar (who played for Liverpool);

“From the vantage point of today’s [English] Premier League, in which almost every team has at least one African in its line-up, it seems remarkable that in 1992, when the Premier League began, the two established African stars of the top-flight of English football were both Zimbabwean.”

And what is perhaps more intriguing is that these two heroes were Zimbabwean in a way that challenged the conventional construction of this identity, often idealised as ‘black’ and ‘Shona’. Ndlovu was from the second largest tribe in Zimbabwe, the Ndebele; by the 1990s, a long history of antagonism and conflict between the Shona and the Ndebele had marred relationships, with the effects of Gukurahundi – a 1980s state-authorised military operation that led to the massacre of thousands of Ndebele lives – still foremost in many minds. Grobbelaar was a white player who had served for two years in the Rhodesian Army in the white minority’s protracted battle against black nationalist rule.  At the time, his participation in the team – even as racial tensions continued to simmer in post-Independence Zimbabwe – appeared to authenticate the famous statements of Robert Mugabe at his 1980 swearing in as Prime Minister where he stated;

“If yesterday I fought as an enemy, today you have become a friend. If yesterday you hated me, today you cannot avoid the love that binds you to me, and me to you.”

Beyond Grobbelaar and Ndlovu, however, the team also featured a coloured player, Henry McKop, who played in defense and midfielder Benjamin Nkonjera, of Malawian descent; two further identities that often suffered the status of ‘other’ in nationalist constructions. In many ways, the Dream Team – kitted out in the colours of the national flag and working towards a collective goal under the banner of a fairly nascent Zimbabwe – represented more than just the dream of football excellence; they represented the dream of a united nation.

As a result, popular representations of the Dream Team often played on notions of fearlessness and dedication.  In a song that became the rousing call to stand behind the team – sung both in Shona and Ndebele featuring dramatic twangs of a guitar fused with urgent screeches of a referee’s whistle – Tanga wekwa Sando likens the team’s opposition to hunted animals ready for roasting, and their fierce play to that of insatiable lions. And in a popular television advertisement for a men’s deodorant, Grobbelaar assures the viewer in heavily accented Shona of the product’s dependability, and more subliminally the Dream Team, stating “Haikurasise”.[1]

And yet, despite these associations with invincibility and an improbable dream, the team never lived up to its name, neither qualifying for the African Cup of Nations nor the World Cup during a time when almost anything seemed possible for Zimbabwe.

Beyond the dream

The metaphor of the Dream Team could easily stand for the great hopes and expectations that many held for Zimbabwe in the heady days of its newly claimed freedom. And yet, the dream was never the reality of the Zimbabwe of the 1980s and 1990s, but rather an essentialist ideal that often erased the nation’s unresolved challenges.

As Susan Baeller[2] notes,

“… football pitches offer arenas not only for the match, but also for the production of public spheres and imaginary spaces where social, cultural and political praxis and discourses are created, celebrated and negotiated.”

In the same way that the dominance of the Dream Team proved to be imaginary, so too was the idea of an indomitable Zimbabwe by the mid-1990s. Backed by the World Bank with its neoliberal imperatives towards liberalisation and privatisation, the Economic Structural Adjustment Programme (ESAP) Zimbabwe had adopted in 1990 was beginning to return woeful results including contraction of the economy and an explosion in inflation; impacts further exacerbated by a period of severe drought that crippled productivity.  An estimated 200 000 skilled professionals are thought to have fled Zimbabwe between 1990 and 1998[3], a portent of the millions to follow thereafter.

Rifts in national identity still manifested strongly in domestic football, with the rivalry between Highlanders – commonly constructed as a ‘Ndebele team’ – and Dynamos – its ‘Shona counterpart’ – symbols of unresolved tribal conflict, with matches between the two often being volatile and highly emotional. Such constructions have been encouraged, for example, by the chants and songs adopted by supporters of each team during matches. One chant (in Ndebele) of Highlanders’ fans sates, “Hakula Shona lihlala eSoweto[4], while a Dynamos chant states, “MaNdevere munoapireiko doro/ Mandevere musaape doro havazogeze”[5]. At the same time, white football enthusiasts had all but abandoned their interest in local football, investing their support instead into sports like tennis, cricket and rugby.

A parachutist, with the Zimbabwean flag trailing him, begins his descent into Zimbabwe’s National Sports Stadium on Independence Day.

The politics of a beautiful game

Today, the myth of Zimbabwean prosperity and unity walks a tenuous line, especially within the current state of affairs where a leadership crisis, a frustrated public and a financial meltdown threaten to take Zimbabwe back to the bleak days of 2008, a time of near-complete shutdown as a result of mass shortages of basic commodities and aggressive hyperinflation. A 2010 FAIR investigation into football management in eight African countries, including Zimbabwe, found that;

“… while players have sacrificed their personal fortunes to develop not just soccer but their own communities, and have in some cases bailed out their national teams, the administrators tasked with developing the game focus on personal gain.”

While Zimbabwe – with a mix of new players and those from the Dream Team era – would eventually go on to qualify for the African Cup of Nations in 2004 and 2006 (exiting both tournaments in the first round), the administration of the game has grown to become one of its biggest talking points.

In the early 2000s, Leo Mugabe, a nephew of the president, was fired from his position as Zimbabwe Football Association (ZIFA) CEO after failing to account for a FIFA youth development grant worth US$61 000. In what is commonly referred to as the ‘Asiagate’ match-fixing scandal, 80 footballers were suspended for their alleged involvement in throwing football matches against Asian teams. In one match against Malaysia, players for local football club Monomotapa are said to have misrepresented themselves as the national team.  For her role in the scandal, Henrietta Rushwaya, ZIFA CEO at that time, would be arrested and later acquitted on charges of failing to disclose details of such matches to the Association. Among her other misdemeanours during her tenure would be taking a loan, unaccounted for, to the value of US$103 000.

And more recently, ZIFA’s Chairman Cuthbert Dube –  widely known for fraudulent conduct which saw him benefit millions of US dollars from corruption within companies including one of Zimbabwe’s largest medical aid societies – resigned from his position, avoiding a likely ouster for his complicity in the body’s dysfunction. He has since been replaced by the equally controversial millionaire businessman, socialite and former ZANU-PF parliamentarian, Phillip Chiyangwa.

Early in 2015, FIFA expelled Zimbabwe’s national football team from the 2018 World Cup qualifiers for ZIFA’s failure to pay Jose Claudinei Georgini, a former national coach, outstanding salaries amounting to US$ 60 000. A further suspension from the 2022 World Cup has loomed over Zimbabwe over another debt of US$ 180 000 owed to former coach, Tom Saintfiet.  The debt is reportedly being financed, however, by Wicknell Chivayo – a controversial businessman known for his ostentatious social media posts which include photographs of bricks of tens of thousands of US dollars at his breakfast table – who last year pledged US$ 1 million in sponsorship to ZIFA. He was quickly reported to have however rescinded the pledge on reports that disbursements had already been mismanaged. He later reinstated the pledge.

The dream deferred

With the decline of Zimbabwean football increasingly mimicking the disrepair and selfishness of the nation’s politics, it is unfortunately the dream for prosperity that continues to suffer. Indeed, the Dream Team remains a metaphor for many things in Zimbabwe; a symbol of the “good old days”, an emblem of hope, a longing for former dignity. This in part explains the exponential growth the #ThisFlag campaign, a movement that spoke to Zimbabweans – mostly online, both in Zimbabwe and Zimbabwe’s diasporas – to share their non-partisan interpretations of, and allegiance to, the Zimbabwean flag; as well as their desires for the nation’s future amid multiple and recurrent tribulations.

But just as our interrogation of our nation’s past and present requires more thorough and nuanced critique, so too do the symbols we now hold on to as markers of a previous glory that might never have really been.

There is ongoing need to ask ourselves just how “good” those days really were, and whether we may have willfully ignored the spectre of the present in our moment of hopeful euphoria. For even the Dream Team – with all the talent, support and potential it promised and excited – remained just that.

A dream.

—–

This article was originally published on This Is Africa and can be seen here. The main photograph in the article is taken from http://www.nehandaradio.com

[1]                  It won’t let you down.

[2]                  Baeller, S. (2006). The other game: the politics of football in Africa (editorial). Afrika Spectrum 41 (3): 325-330.

[3]                Pasura, D. (2011). A Fractured Transnational Diaspora: The Case of Zimbabweans in Britain. URL: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-2435.2010.00675.x/full

[4]                “There is no Shona who will sit in Soweto.” Soweto a popular stand for Highlanders supporters during home matches. Quoted from Ncube, L. (2014). The interface between football and ethnic identity discourses in Zimbabwe. Critical African Studies 6 (2-3): 192-210.

[5]                “Why do you give Ndebeles beer?/ Don’t give them beer as they won’t bathe.” Quoted from Ncube, L. (2014). The interface between football and ethnic identity discourses in Zimbabwe. Critical African Studies 6 (2-3): 192-210.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s